Steak and Stardom: The Celebrity Chronicles of Jim's Steak House

Where Celebrities Dine and Ordinary Meets Extraordinary: The Star-Studded Tales of Jim's Steak House

Nestled near the Peoria Civic Center, Jim’s Steak House has been a culinary hotspot attracting a plethora of celebrities over the years. Manager Kristin Comfort fondly recalls how famous faces often pop in to enjoy the restaurant’s fine dining experience. “Celebrities who visit usually remember us and often return when they're back in Peoria,” Comfort shared, emphasizing her father's commitment to making Jim’s a welcoming venue. The restaurant's charm and steak offerings have made it a favorite pit stop for stars from various walks of entertainment.

One of the most memorable visits was from Robert Plant, the legendary singer of Led Zeppelin. Comfort recalled an amusing encounter between a waitress and Plant, who was dining with a group. “She jokingly asked if they were in a band," Comfort said, brushing off the initial surprise of serving such a rock icon. Plant’s casual visit to the steakhouse reflects the down-to-earth appeal of Jim's, where even rock legends feel at home.

Another notable celebrity who frequented Jim's was Ray Liotta, famed for his roles in classic films like “Goodfellas” and “Field of Dreams.” In the 1990s, Liotta visited the restaurant with his then-wife, local actress Michelle Grace, herself an alumna of Richwoods High School in Peoria. Comfort fondly remembers Liotta as "a really neat guy," highlighting the warm interactions guests have with the staff and each other at Jim’s.

Comedians also find their way to Jim’s table. Jay Leno, the iconic late-night host, enjoyed a lunch at the restaurant, marking one of Comfort's few face-to-face experiences with a celebrity. The art of laughter continued with frequent visitor Hal Holbrook, famed for his participation in films like “All the President’s Men.” Holbrook loved Jim's so much that he requested an early opening for breakfast on occasion. Comfort chuckled as she recalled, “He was our only customer on those mornings.” Such personalized service showcases the restaurant's dedication to making every visit memorable.

Among the more significant personalities who have graced the establishment is the beloved Ernest Borgnine. Known for his roles in “Marty” and “McHale’s Navy,” Borgnine was described by Comfort as a “very nice, pleasant man.” At 91 years old, he visited Jim’s and ordered the restaurant's ravioli, embodying the relaxed yet exquisite dining experience the steakhouse offers. Comfort recounted the endearing presence of celebrities like Borgnine, who make their mark on the restaurant's history with their kindness.

Eddie Murphy, the comedic genius behind iconic characters in movies like “Coming to America” and “Shrek,” also visited Jim's earlier in his career. Comfort shared a captivating tale from the late 1980s when Murphy's bus rolled up to the bustling patio. “The crowd erupted in applause as he walked in,” Comfort recounted, painting a vivid picture of the entertainment world colliding with the local dining scene. The moment encapsulated the star-studded yet personal allure of Jim's Steak House.

David Carradine, known for his role in the television series “Kung Fu,” made an impression during his visit by taking pictures with the staff and customers, highlighting the friendly and inclusive atmosphere at Jim's. Chevy Chase, another comedy legend famous for his role in “National Lampoon’s Vacation,” surprised visitors with a visit while celebrating the 35th anniversary of the holiday classic “National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation.” Comfort commented, “He was just a really nice guy, enjoying time with his family,” exemplifying the familial aura that permeates Jim’s.

A recurring figure in the restaurant was The Amazing Kreskin, the renowned mentalist. Comfort speaks warmly of Kreskin, noting how he would often engage in lengthy conversations with her father, establishing a genuine friendship. “They would sit for hours just talking,” she said, reminiscing about the unique rapport that blossomed over time. Even after Kreskin returned home, he continued to foster their connection by sending Christmas cards, now displayed on the walls of Jim's Steak House along with various celebrity memorabilia.

Interestingly, while Elton John never dined inside the restaurant, his presence was felt through a to-go order placed after a performance nearby. The staff delivered the meal to his tour bus, further intertwining the celebrity culture with the daily routines at Jim's. Comfort proudly showcases a signed portrait of the music icon alongside memorabilia recognizing his connection to the restaurant.

As Jim’s Steak House continues to thrive, its history of celebrity encounters adds an exhilarating dimension to its legacy. Comfort’s passion for her family's establishment shines through as she shares each heartfelt story of stars like Robert Plant, Ray Liotta, and Eddie Murphy. Each visit not only contributes to the restaurant’s rich narrative but also solidifies Jim's Steak House as a cherished gathering place for celebrities and locals alike. Whether it’s a casual lunch or a surprise appearance, Jim’s has successfully created a dining experience where everyone feels like a VIP, adding a hint of Hollywood sparkle to the heart of Peoria.