Costume Chronicles: Celebrity Halloween Hits and Misses of 2023

From Epic Fails to Creative Triumphs: Celebrities Weigh In on Halloween's Best and Worst Costumes of 2023

Halloween is a unique holiday that provides grown-ups, especially celebrities, a chance to showcase their creativity through costumes without the fear of judgment. For most of us, costume choices are lighthearted and often humorous, but in the glitzy world of fame and fortune, expectations run high. When it comes to Halloween, fans anticipate costumes that are elaborate, unique, and even trend-setting. This year's Halloween offerings from celebrities did not disappoint entirely, as some star-studded looks dazzled, while others left us wondering what happened.

One of the most talked-about costumes this year was Demi Lovato's tribute to her fictional twin sister, Poot, a character born from a viral photo that captured the internet's attention. Lovato's clever nod to her internet meme saw her donning a character that originated from the depths of a basement, showcasing her sense of humor and creativity. Her unexpected choice had fans in stitches, proving that a celebrity can still embrace playful fun amidst the elaborate pressure of Halloween costumes.

Meanwhile, actress Emma Roberts, known for her role in "American Horror Story," fell short of expectations at Vas J. Morgan and Michael Braun's Halloween bash. Dressed in a vintage white nightgown paired with a long black wig, her look was reminiscent of classic horror tropes but lacked originality. Although the fake cut on her neck added some intrigue, it wasn't enough to elevate the costume from the ordinary. With her well-established status as a scream queen, many fans hoped for something more thrilling, but she ended up in the unfortunate spotlight of the worst-dressed list at Coachella as well.

Hailey Bieber, usually a trendsetter in the celebrity fashion world, took a more family-friendly route this Halloween by dressing up as Mrs. Incredible alongside her son. While cute and relatable, many remarked that the choice felt less inspiring than one might expect from someone with Bieber's style credentials. Despite her significant influence in fashion, this costume was a fairly safe, pedestrian choice that fell flat when compared to her capabilities for innovation. After all, Halloween is the perfect opportunity for celebrities to push the envelope and showcase their creativity.

Victoria Justice, another star with roots in Nickelodeon, also opted for familiar Halloween tropes, dressing as both a devil and a bloody bride. While well-executed, these costumes seemed more like last-minute decisions rather than the standout looks Justice is capable of delivering. Hosting a Halloween party to celebrate her album "Love Zombie," fans anticipated something more riveting from an artist who has often channeled the horror genre in her work. The choices were disappointingly conventional and left us wanting a greater spectacle.

The Kardashian clan is well-known for their extravagant Halloween bashes, and 2025 was no exception. Khloé Kardashian hosted a delightful family gathering adorned with impressive decorations, sweets, and other celebrity guests, including Meghan Trainor. Both Khloé and Meghan dressed as fairies, a common costume choice that, while fun, felt uninspired and repetitive. Given that the atmosphere was lively and whimsical, many felt that the fairies theme had been overdone, leaving viewers hoping for something fresher from the prominent reality TV family.

Actress Lindsay Lohan also joined the Halloween festivities with her version of a 'Batman family' alongside her husband and child; while undeniably cute, this choice lacked the creative flair typically associated with Lohan's past iconic looks. Having starred in movies that became Halloween staples, such as "Mean Girls," her own costume felt anticlimactic compared to the roles that inspired many memorable Halloween personas. Meanwhile, AnnaSophia Robb's fairy costume at "The Cursed Amulet" Halloween party elicited little excitement. The standard fairy wings and pointed ears seemed too simplistic for an event where the extraordinary is expected, leaving impressionable little to respond to.

Bebe Rexha stirred curiosity with her unique interpretation of a fairy, featuring a yellow latex dress paired with fluffy wings. The ensemble raised eyebrows for its ambiguity, leaving fans questioning whether it was a niche reference or simply a missed opportunity for creativity. The lack of cohesion in her costume limited its effectiveness, and it served as a reminder that Halloween is all about fun and innovation. Lastly, actress Famke Janssen graced Heidi Klum's renowned Halloween party dressed as a sultry ringmaster. While she looked stunning, the outfit came off as more suitable for a casual gathering rather than the highly anticipated event that Klum curates annually. For the celebrities attending such a prominent party, expectations to impress and surprise are elevated, and Janssen’s look, while attractive, did not reach the anticipated heights.

As we finalize our thoughts on this year in celebrity Halloween costumes, it’s clear that while some stars rose to the occasion, others opted for simple, predictable looks that felt uncharacteristic of their usual creativity. Now, as we look ahead, it will be fascinating to compare and dissect the costumes of 2024's Halloween, seeing if our favorite stars learn from this year's missteps or continue with choices that leave fans wanting more. Celebrities have the unique ability to amaze and inspire every October 31st, and it’s the hope of their fans that one day, they will unleash even more imaginative and unforgettable costumes to mark the occasion.